Inside Edge
  • Home
  • Services
  • Mike's Blog
  • Contact
  • Qualifications
  • FAQs
  • Sample Report
  • Pricing
  • Guarantees

Mike's Home Inspector Blog

InterNACHI Certified Professional Inspector
Halifax, Nova Scotia

Ionization vs Photoelectric Detectors

8/28/2022

0 Comments

 
…or why I have two smoke detectors next to each other in the basement. 

One of the biggest safety issues I see in my home inspections is also one that is easy to remedy: the lack of smoke detectors or (more commonly) the prevalence of smoke detectors that are past the 10-year life expectancy and should be replaced. It’s an easy fix: almost every hardware store sells them for a very affordable price. They are not only an invaluable life safety device that can save lives but, along with fire extinguishers, can help stop a fire from becoming out of control and destroying a home.  As mentioned, I have two smoke detectors in very close in proximity in the basement. The obvious reason for this is so that there is no question we will hear the alarm upstairs while sleeping and as a backup if one fails, but it is a little more complicated than that. The main reason is that the detector present when we moved in was ionization and I wanted an photoelectric alarm, especially near the dryer. Does this mean a photoelectric detector is better? The truth is more complicated than that. 

Ionization Advantages
The biggest advantage of this type of detector is that it is superior in detecting flaming fires. In other words, fast moving fires that can quickly overwhelm occupants and block escape routes. This would be fires as the result of paper, wood or flammable liquids to give a few examples. These detectors are, believe it or not, filled with a radioactive substance called Americium. As scary as that sounds, the amount is astronomically tiny and poses no threat as long as they are not deliberately dismantled. In my experience, most smoke detectors utilize ionization technology. 
​

Why Use a Photoelectric Detector?
Photoelectric smoke detectors are better at detecting smoldering fires, which are fires that are barely visible with a lazy haze of smoke, often for hours. A common example would be a burning cigarette, and a photoelectric detector can alert occupants to a situation that can lead to a flaming fire and give time to act (either fight or flee) accordingly.
Picture
Picture
Which is Better?
I will again use my most common stock phrase and say “it depends” but the most important fact is that placement is far more important than what type you have. The simple facts are: 
  • Both types of detectors detect both types of fires, just at different timescales
  • There is no way to predict if a house fire will be a smoldering or a flaming fire
  • Ionization alarms are much slower at detecting smoldering fires compared to photoelectric alarms sounding in flaming fires, but this can be offset somewhat by how rapidly flaming fires spread. 
  • It is FAR more important to actually have working smoke alarms than worrying about whether you have the right one.

While it is a great idea to know the difference between the two types of residential smoke detectors, this is not generally something that home inspectors note. What IS important is that smoke detectors are installed, are working, and are well placed to maximize safety and minimize nuisance alarms. It is concerning that few homes have proper smoke detectors installed and this is one of the easiest and cheapest DIY jobs. I hope that one day I will never again hear about a fatality caused by occupants not being aware of a house fire and being unable to escape in time. 
0 Comments

    Archives

    June 2025
    May 2025
    April 2025
    March 2025
    February 2025
    January 2025
    December 2024
    November 2024
    October 2024
    September 2024
    August 2024
    July 2024
    June 2024
    May 2024
    April 2024
    March 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    December 2023
    November 2023
    October 2023
    September 2023
    August 2023
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    February 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    October 2022
    September 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    June 2022
    May 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    February 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021

    Categories

    All
    AED
    Aerial Photography
    AFCI
    AI
    Air Conditioning
    Aluminum
    Anode Rod
    Ants
    Arcs
    Arsenic
    Asbestos
    ASD
    Attic
    Autism
    Balcony
    Basement
    Brick
    Building Inspector
    Carbon Monoxide
    ChatGPT
    Children
    Chimney
    Chinese Drywall
    Christmas
    Circuit Breakers
    Cliches
    Clocks
    CO Detectors
    Communication
    Concrete
    Contractors
    Copper
    Cost
    Criticisms
    Current
    Data
    Deck
    Doors
    Drains
    Drone
    Drywall
    DWV
    Eavestroughs
    EIFS
    Electrical
    ERV
    Exterior
    Failed Seals
    Female Inspectors
    Fiber Cement
    Fibreglass
    Fibreglass Shingles
    Fireplaces
    Fire Safety
    First Aid
    First Time Homebuyers
    Flips
    Flooding
    Flooring
    Fluoride
    Foundation
    Framing
    Fuses
    Garage
    Garage Doors
    Garage Safety
    Gfci
    Growops
    Heating
    Heat Pumps
    Hgtv
    Hoarding
    Home Inspectors
    Hrv
    Humidity
    HVAC
    Ice Dams
    ICF
    Infrared
    Insulation
    Ionization
    Joe Mazza
    Kitchen
    Kitec
    Knob & Tube
    Lead
    LGBT
    Manufactured Houses
    Marijuana
    Masonry
    Meth
    Mike Holmes
    Mineral Wool
    Mini Homes
    Misconceptions
    Mobile Homes
    Moisture
    Mold
    Newcomers
    New Inspectors
    Oil Tanks
    Open Concept
    Orangeburg
    Patina
    Personal Decor
    Pests
    Photoelectric
    Plumbing
    Polybutylene
    Pressure
    Price
    Professionalism
    Psychrometrics
    Radon
    Rain Gutters
    Real Estate Agents
    Regulations
    Remodelling
    Renovations
    Resistance
    Ridge Vent
    Roofing
    Rust
    Safety
    Scams
    Septic
    Sewer
    Sewer Scopes
    Sheds
    Shipping Containers
    Siding
    Smoke Detectors
    Smoking
    Soffits
    Staircases
    Steel
    Stove
    Structure
    Stucco
    Sump Pump
    Swamp Coolers
    Temperature
    Termites
    Trailer Parks
    Trees
    Value
    Ventilation
    Ventless Heaters
    Vinyl
    Voltage
    Walls
    Wasps
    Water Heater
    Water Testing
    WDOs
    Windows
    Wiring
    Wood
    Wood Rot

    RSS Feed

Picture
Inside Edge Home Inspections Ltd. 
Halifax, NS
902-209-9921
[email protected]
Proudly Serving the HRM & Central Nova Scotia
Picture
  • Home
  • Services
  • Mike's Blog
  • Contact
  • Qualifications
  • FAQs
  • Sample Report
  • Pricing
  • Guarantees